← All articles

By ·

Retail and Franchise Site Selection with GIS: A Method That Survives the Real Estate Committee

Retail site selection with GIS in 7 steps, from trade area and demand to cannibalization and validation, with a Huff gravity model worked by hand.

Aerial view of a large shopping centre surrounded by parking lots and arterial roads
Photo: Point3D Commercial Imaging Ltd. on Unsplash

Retail site selection with GIS means estimating, for each candidate location, who can reach it, how much they spend, how much of that spending competitors and your own stores will take, and then checking the model against your existing stores. A method survives the real estate committee when every number traces to data and the forecast error is stated.

This article sets out a seven-step method for retail and franchise site selection, a Huff gravity model worked by hand, how to measure cannibalization, the US and Canadian data sources to use, and when this approach is the wrong one.

What does a real estate committee need from a site selection study?

A real estate committee is deciding whether to sign a lease or approve a franchisee's location. It does not need a beautiful heat map. It needs answers to five questions:

  1. How much will this store sell? As a range, not a point.
  2. Where will those sales come from? New customers, competitors, or our own stores.
  3. What could make it wrong? Access, visibility, a competitor opening, a co-tenant closing.
  4. How does it compare with the alternatives? Other sites in the same market, ranked on the same basis.
  5. How much do we trust the model? How it performed on stores we already have.

Most GIS site selection work answers the first and fourth questions with a score and skips the second, third and fifth. That is where studies die in committee. The method below is built around all five.

What data do you need for retail site selection in the US and Canada?

NeedUnited StatesCanada
Population, households, income, ageAmerican Community Survey 5-year estimates at block group level (about 600 to 3,000 people each)2021 Census Profile by dissemination area (average 400 to 700 people)
Small-area boundariesCensus TIGER/Line block groupsDissemination Area Boundary Files
Road network and drive timesOpenStreetMap with OSRM or Valhalla, or a commercial engine such as Esri or HERESame
Competitors and co-tenantsYour own competitor list, Overture Maps places, OpenStreetMapSame
Visits and foot trafficMobility data vendors such as Advan (which bought SafeGraph's Patterns business in 2022) and Placer.aiCheck each vendor's Canadian coverage before buying
Your own performanceStore sales, square footage, opening dates, loyalty or delivery addressesSame

The last row is the most valuable and the most often ignored. Customer addresses from a loyalty program or delivery orders tell you the real shape of each store's trade area. No purchased dataset is a substitute for that.

Two practical differences between the countries. US reports usually describe distances in miles and Canadian reports in kilometres, so state the unit in every table. And ACS figures are survey estimates with published margins of error, while Canadian DA profiles come from the census of a single reference year, so in fast-growing suburbs both can be stale in different ways.

How do you do retail site selection with GIS, step by step?

Step 1: Define the trade area by drive time, not radius

Draw each candidate's trade area as a drive-time catchment at the hour your customers travel. Use your existing stores' customer data to choose the time: if 70% of a typical store's customers live within 12 minutes, use 12 minutes.

Rings are tempting because they are simple, but in a test of 169 Calgary sites, a 3-mile ring and a 10-minute drive differed in population by more than 25% at 42% of sites, and only 4 of the top 10 sites were the same under both methods. The full comparison is in drive-time vs radius trade areas.

Step 2: Measure demand

Demand is not population. It is the number of the right households multiplied by what they spend in your category. For each small area (block group or DA) inside the trade area, estimate:

Step 3: Map competition

List every competitor a customer would consider a substitute, with an attractiveness measure for each: floor area, number of service bays, seats, or a brand weight. This becomes the competitive set in the Huff model below. Missing one large competitor will inflate every forecast nearby, so ask local operators to check the list.

Step 4: Score accessibility and visibility

Drive time captures how far a site is. It does not capture whether a driver can get in. Check, on site or with street-level imagery:

These are usually scored as adjustments, not modelled. Record them explicitly so the committee sees them.

Step 5: Account for co-tenancy

Neighbouring tenants change traffic. A grocery anchor, a big-box store or a busy coffee shop can bring trips your site would not generate alone. Treat strong anchors as a bonus to attractiveness, and record which lease clauses depend on them. If the anchor leaves, the forecast should be rerun.

Step 6: Estimate sales and cannibalization with a gravity model

Combine demand, competition and travel time in a Huff model, worked in full in the next section. Run it twice, with and without the new site, to see how much of the new store's sales come from your own stores.

Step 7: Score, then validate against existing stores

Turn the outputs into a score or a sales forecast, then test the method on the stores you already have before using it on new sites. Details are in the validation section below.

How does the Huff model estimate a new store's sales?

The Huff model comes from David Huff's 1964 paper Defining and Estimating a Trading Area in the Journal of Marketing. It treats store choice as a probability. The probability that a shopper in zone i chooses store j is:

P(i, j) = (S_j^α ÷ T_ij^λ) ÷ Σ_k (S_k^α ÷ T_ik^λ)

where:

Each store's estimated sales are the sum, over all zones, of P(i, j) multiplied by zone i's spending in the category.

The worked example

Three stores, four demand zones. Stores A and C belong to your brand. B is a competitor. C is the site under review.

StoreOwnerFloor area (thousand sq ft)
AYou, existing20
BCompetitor40
CYou, proposed25
ZoneAnnual category spendingDrive time to Ato Bto C
Z1$12.0M5 min10 min8 min
Z2$8.0M12 min6 min9 min
Z3$15.0M9 min15 min4 min
Z4$5.0M14 min8 min12 min
Total$40.0M

Step 1: Compute each store's pull from each zone

Pull = floor area ÷ (drive time)². For Z1 and store A: 20 ÷ 5² = 20 ÷ 25 = 0.800.

ZonePull of APull of BPull of CTotal pull
Z120/25 = 0.800040/100 = 0.400025/64 = 0.39061.5906
Z220/144 = 0.138940/36 = 1.111125/81 = 0.30861.5586
Z320/81 = 0.246940/225 = 0.177825/16 = 1.56251.9872
Z420/196 = 0.102040/64 = 0.625025/144 = 0.17360.9007

Step 2: Convert pull to probabilities

Divide each pull by the zone's total. Each row adds to 1, allowing for rounding.

ZoneP(A)P(B)P(C)
Z10.5030.2510.246
Z20.0890.7130.198
Z30.1240.0890.786
Z40.1130.6940.193

Step 3: Multiply by spending to get captured sales

Figures are in millions of dollars, to three decimals so the rows and columns add up.

ZoneSpendingA capturesB capturesC captures
Z112.0006.0353.0182.947
Z28.0000.7135.7031.584
Z315.0001.8641.34211.794
Z45.0000.5663.4700.964
Total40.0009.17813.53317.289

The three stores' sales add to $40.0M, the full market, as the model requires. Rounded: A $9.18M, B $13.53M, C $17.29M.

Step 4: Rerun without the new store to measure cannibalization

With only A and B in the market, the same calculation gives A $18.31M and B $21.69M.

Without CWith CChange
Store A (yours)$18.31M$9.18M−$9.13M
Store B (competitor)$21.69M$13.53M−$8.16M
Store C (yours, new)n/a$17.29M+$17.29M
Your brand total$18.31M$26.47M+$8.16M

Store C's forecast of $17.29M looks excellent on its own. But $9.13M of it, 53%, comes out of your own store A. The net gain to the brand is $8.16M, which is exactly what C takes from the competitor. That is the number the committee should see first, and in a franchise system it is also the number the franchisee who owns store A will ask about.

Step 5: Check how sensitive the answer is to the decay exponent

The exponent λ = 2 above was chosen for illustration. It should be calibrated, and the answer moves when it changes:

λC's forecastA's loss to CNet new to the brandShare of C's sales cannibalized
1$15.01M$6.18M$8.83M41%
2$17.29M$9.13M$8.16M53%
3$17.90M$11.53M$6.36M64%

A steeper decay makes the new store look stronger on its own, because shoppers in Z3 stick to the nearest store, but it also makes it eat more of store A. The net new revenue falls from $8.83M to $6.36M. If you only report C's own forecast, you will be most optimistic exactly when cannibalization is worst.

Calibrate α and λ from your own stores' customer origins and sales. Esri's Business Analyst has a Huff model tool and a separate calibration tool for this, and the same fit can be done in Python or R.

Bar charts from the Huff model worked example: brand sales rise from $18.31M without store C to $26.47M with it, of which $9.13M of C's $17.29M comes from store A; the share of C's sales taken from A is 41%, 53% and 64% at decay exponents of 1, 2 and 3

The worked example in one picture: store C's headline forecast versus what the brand actually gains, and how the answer moves with the decay exponent.

How do you score and validate candidate sites?

A Huff forecast covers demand, competition and travel time. Access, visibility and co-tenancy usually enter as a scored adjustment. A simple structure:

ComponentMeasureWeight
Net new salesHuff forecast minus cannibalizationLargest single weight
Access and visibilitySite visit scorecardSet from experience
Co-tenancyAnchor strength and lease dependencySet from experience
RiskPipeline competitors, road works, anchor lease expiryPenalty

Weights are a judgement. The validation is what makes them defensible:

  1. Score every existing store with the same model and the data that existed when it opened, where you have it.
  2. Compare scores or forecasts with actual sales, after the store has matured.
  3. Check the ranking. If the model's top quarter of existing stores are not mostly your actual top performers, change the model, not the committee's minds.
  4. Hold out stores. Calibrate on most stores and test on the rest, so you are not grading the model on its own homework.
  5. Report the error. If the model's forecasts on existing stores were typically off by 20%, the new site's forecast is a range of plus or minus 20%, and the committee should see that range.

A system with only a handful of stores cannot calibrate much. In that case say so, use analogues from similar markets, and lean more on the drive-time demand and competition maps than on a precise sales number.

How did this method work on a franchise rollout?

I built GIS-based location scoring for Taleemabad to guide a nationwide school franchise rollout, ranking catchments by population, competition and accessibility using QGIS, census data and OpenStreetMap. The structure was the one above, with schools in place of stores: population as the demand layer, existing schools as the competition layer, and the accessibility of each catchment as the third.

Two lessons from that kind of work carry over to retail franchising:

You can see the same kind of coverage analysis applied to fire stations in the Site Selection Showdown map game on this site.

What about protected territories in franchise systems?

A franchise site that scores well can still be off the table if it falls inside a territory already granted to another franchisee, or so close to one that it invites a dispute. Before scoring, overlay every candidate on the current territory map and screen out conflicts. If the territories were drawn as rings or ZIP code lists, that check can be messier than it sounds. Franchise territory mapping covers how to draw territories that hold up, and how they connect to the disclosure document.

When is GIS site selection the wrong approach?

How much does a site selection study cost?

It depends mainly on how many sites are reviewed, whether you have usable customer data for calibration, and whether mobility data has to be bought. A study of a few shortlisted sites using public census data and an existing competitor list is a much smaller job than a market-wide model calibrated on a store network. For rates and how quotes are put together, see GIS consultant cost.

If you need a site selection study or a franchise location model scoped or done, email me at mahad.imran29@gmail.com.

Frequently asked questions

What data do you need for retail site selection?

At minimum: population and household data for small areas (American Community Survey block groups in the US, Statistics Canada dissemination areas in Canada), a road network for drive times, competitor and co-tenant locations, and your own store sales with customer origins. Mobility or foot-traffic data from vendors such as Advan or Placer.ai helps where you lack customer addresses, but it is a supplement, not a substitute for your own sales history.

How does the Huff model work in simple terms?

The Huff model says a shopper's chance of choosing a store rises with the store's attractiveness, usually size, and falls with travel time or distance raised to a decay exponent. Each store's pull is divided by the total pull of all stores the shopper could use, giving probabilities that add to one. Multiply those probabilities by each zone's spending to estimate each store's sales.

How do you measure cannibalization when opening a new franchise location?

Run the sales model twice, once with the existing network and competitors only, and once with the new site added. The drop in sales at your existing stores is cannibalization. The new site's forecast minus that drop is the net new revenue to the brand. In the worked example in this article, more than half of the new store's forecast sales came from the brand's own nearby store.

How accurate are GIS site selection models?

Only as accurate as their validation shows. Before using a model on new sites, score your existing stores with it and compare against their actual sales. If the model cannot rank existing stores in roughly the right order, it will not rank new sites correctly either. Report the error you measured on existing stores as the forecast range for new ones.

Is franchise site selection different from corporate retail site selection?

The analysis is the same, but franchise systems add two constraints. New sites must respect protected territories already granted to franchisees, and the forecast is used by a franchisee who is investing their own money. That makes cannibalization and territory encroachment as important as the sales estimate itself.

Let's talk.

Best way to reach me is email. I respond to most things.