← All articles

By ·

How Many Stations Is Enough? Reading the Coverage Curve Before You Build

Station coverage has steep diminishing returns. In Calgary 6 stations reach 96% of residents in 12 minutes, but covering everyone takes 39. How to read the curve.

A coverage curve shows how many people a given number of stations can reach within a response-time standard, when each count is placed as well as possible. In three cities tested at a 12-minute drive, the first few stations reached most residents and the curve then flattened fast. Calgary reached 96% with 6 stations, but covering every reachable resident took 39.

This article shows how to build that curve, what the three test cities say about it, why adding stations one at a time does worse than planning them together, and how to use the curve when a council asks how many stations it actually needs.

What is a coverage curve?

A coverage curve plots two things against each other:

Each point on the curve is its own optimization. The point at 4 stations is the best possible placement of 4 stations, found from scratch, and it does not have to share any sites with the best placement of 3.

The model behind each point is the maximal covering location problem (MCLP), introduced by Church and ReVelle in 1974. It fixes the number of facilities and places them to cover as much demand as possible within a distance or time standard. Its partner, the location set covering problem, asks the reverse question: the fewest facilities needed to cover all demand. Both are explained in more depth, with a worked Calgary example at the NFPA 4-minute standard, in fire station location analysis.

The curve matters because neither single answer is what a decision maker needs. "4 stations cover 84%" and "39 stations cover everyone" are both true. The useful information is the shape between them.

How was this test set up?

I used the three cities behind the Site Selection Showdown game on this site, which share one method:

CityModelled populationAreaHexagonsCandidate sites
Calgary1,463,328853 km²1,2051,114
Islamabad Capital Territory2,590,233963 km²1,164906
Bahawalpur673,192399 km²542308

What do the coverage curves look like?

Left: coverage curves for Calgary, Islamabad and Bahawalpur from 1 to 20 stations at a 12-minute drive, rising steeply and flattening. Right: two Calgary maps comparing the best four stations, covering 83.6% of residents, with four stations added one at a time, covering 75.9%

Solid lines: the best placement for each station count. Dashed lines: stations added one at a time, each the best addition given the ones already built.

StationsCalgaryIslamabadBahawalpur
128.1%24.7%55.3%
249.8%45.5%66.5%
368.9%60.0%72.5%
483.6%69.5%77.6%
590.3%75.5%81.4%
695.8%79.6%83.6%
797.6%82.5%85.6%
898.9%85.4%86.4%
1099.6%89.6%87.9%
1599.9%94.9%90.6%
20100.0%96.8%91.7%

Bold marks the first count to pass 80%.

The marginal station

The curve is easier to argue about as the number of new residents each extra station adds:

Station numberCalgary addsIslamabad addsBahawalpur adds
1st411,570638,574372,551
2nd317,565540,01475,307
3rd278,849375,44639,920
4th215,212245,70534,386
5th98,052156,37825,797
6th81,212105,33015,128
7th26,18476,00813,050
8th18,36474,5265,796
9th7,72158,1545,214
10th2,80749,6254,469

In Calgary the 10th station adds less than 1% of what the 1st did. The operating cost of a staffed station does not fall in the same way: a crew costs the same whether it protects 400,000 people or 3,000. That gap is the whole argument for drawing the curve.

What it takes to reach everyone

CalgaryIslamabadBahawalpur
Stations for 80%475
Stations for 90%51114
Stations for 95%616not reachable
Share of residents any candidate can reach99.99%99.55%93.17%
Stations to cover every reachable resident395442

The last row is the location set covering answer. Going from 95% to everyone took Calgary 33 more stations. Islamabad needed 38 more after its 16th. These final stations protect a few hundred to a few thousand people each, scattered on the urban edge.

Why are the three curves so different?

The shape comes from where people live relative to the road network, not from population alone.

The lesson for a client: never borrow another city's number. A rule of thumb such as "one station per 50,000 residents" would give about 29 stations for Calgary, 52 for Islamabad and 13 for Bahawalpur. None of those counts sits at a meaningful point on the curves above.

Is adding one station at a time good enough?

Most real networks grow one station at a time, so it is tempting to plan them that way: pick the best first site, then the best second site given the first, and so on. This is a greedy approach, and it is what happens by default when each new station is justified on its own.

It costs coverage. The dashed lines in the figure show the gap:

StationsCalgary, planned togetherCalgary, one at a timeResidents lost
31,007,984958,26849,716
41,223,1961,110,101113,095
51,321,2481,250,44570,803
61,402,4601,345,71756,743

At four stations, the one-at-a-time network covers 7.7 percentage points fewer Calgarians. Islamabad loses up to 107,252 residents (4.1 points) at four stations. Bahawalpur's loss is smaller, at most 1.5 points, because its curve is dominated by one central site.

The reason is that the best first station is usually a compromise placed in the middle of everything. Once more stations exist, that central position is wasted, because its catchment overlaps with all of them. In Calgary the best set of three stations and the best set of four share only one site. A plan that locked in the first three would never reach the best four.

What this means in practice:

  1. Plan the target network first, for the station count you expect in 10 to 20 years, then decide the build order.
  2. Build toward it. Choose the first stations from the long-term set, ordered by how much each covers on its own. That gives up a little coverage early to avoid a permanent loss later.
  3. Re-solve when the city changes. A new freeway interchange or a large subdivision can move the optimal set. Rerun the curve with existing stations fixed in place, which an integer program handles with one extra constraint per station.

How do you use the curve in a decision?

The curve does not choose a number for you. It shows the trade-off so the decision can be made on purpose.

  1. Fix the standard first. Career fire departments in the US often plan to the 240-second first-engine travel time in NFPA 1710. Volunteer and combination departments use NFPA 1720, which sets 9 minutes for urban demand zones (over 1,000 people per square mile), 10 for suburban and 14 for rural. In Punjab, Rescue 1122 reports a provincial average response time of about 7 minutes. A curve at the wrong standard answers the wrong question.
  2. Draw the curve for that standard, and for one stricter and one looser standard. If the recommended count changes a lot between them, the standard is the real decision, not the count.
  3. Put a cost on the vertical axis. Divide each station's annual operating cost by the residents or incidents it adds. Where that number crosses what the community is willing to pay per person covered, you have a defensible count.
  4. Name the people left out. The flat end of the curve is not empty. It is specific neighbourhoods. Map them and decide whether they get a station, a mutual-aid agreement with a neighbouring service, a rapid-response vehicle, or a lower standard written into policy.
  5. Use incidents if you have them. Population is a proxy for demand. Historical call locations, weighted by severity, are better, and they usually make the curve rise faster because calls cluster more tightly than homes.

What are the limitations of this test?

What should you take from this?

If you are asked how many stations a city needs, answer with a curve, not a number. Solve the best placement for every count from one to well past the current network, mark where the next station adds too few people to justify its cost, and plan the whole network before deciding the order to build it in. Then show the map of who is still outside the line, because that is what the council will be asked about.

If you want a coverage curve and a station plan built for your service area, email me at mahad.imran29@gmail.com.

Frequently asked questions

How many fire or EMS stations does a city need?

It depends on the response-time standard, the road network and where people live, so the honest answer is a curve, not a number. Solve the maximal covering problem for 1, 2, 3 and more stations and plot the share of residents reached. In Calgary, at a 12-minute free-flow drive, 4 stations reach 84%, 6 reach 96%, and reaching every reachable resident takes 39. The right count is where the next station stops being worth its operating cost.

What is a coverage curve in location planning?

A coverage curve plots the best possible coverage, usually the share of population or incidents within a time standard, against the number of facilities. Each point is a separate optimization. The curve rises steeply at first and then flattens, which makes the diminishing returns of each extra station visible and lets a council compare options on one chart.

Is adding stations one at a time as good as planning the whole network?

Usually not. In Calgary, choosing the best first site, then the best second site given the first, and so on, reached 75.9% of residents with four stations. Solving for the best four together reached 83.6%, about 113,000 more people. The best set of four did not even contain the best set of three, apart from one site.

Why can some residents never be covered?

Some homes sit where no buildable site is within the time standard: at the end of long cul-de-sac networks, across rivers with few crossings, or beyond the edge of the road data. In this test 6.8% of Bahawalpur's modelled population could not be reached within 12 minutes from any candidate site. No number of stations fixes that. It needs a different standard, a road link or a different service model.

Which response time standard should I use for station planning?

Use the one your service is held to. Career fire departments in the US often plan to NFPA 1710's 240-second first-engine travel time. Volunteer and combination departments use NFPA 1720, which sets 9 minutes in urban areas, 10 in suburban and 14 in rural. EMS systems and services outside North America set their own targets. Run the curve at more than one standard if the choice is still open.

Let's talk.

Best way to reach me is email. I respond to most things.